Six months have passed since a choice was made. An auditor, a new manager or the board asks: why this option? If the answer lives in a few people's heads and a few scattered files, the decision is not defensible, even if it was right.
Four signs of a defensible decision
- The criteria were written before the options were seen. A criterion written after the choice is a justification, not a criterion.
- Every number has a source. It is clear which document each price and each score came from.
- Opinions were collected independently. When committee members see each other's views, the strongest voice gets repeated.
- The record cannot be changed. If the file can be edited quietly, no part of it can be trusted.
Common mistakes
The decision is made in a meeting and the minutes are written afterwards. Weights are adjusted until the preferred option wins. Conflicts of interest are not declared. None of this is necessarily ill-intentioned, but all of it leaves the decision without a defence.
How BehKav helps
In BehKav the criteria and weights are locked before scoring, each committee member scores alone, every number is linked to its document and every change is written to a chained record. The outcome is a formal report you can put in front of any question.